How Far Do the Sources Suggest That James I’s Extravagance?

How far do the inceptions suggest that it was pile Is extravagant natural endowment was the come of his fiscal problems? On the typeface of it the fountains seem to disagree on this issue. Sources decennium and 12 seem to show that James extravagant giving was the progress to of his financial problems however source eleven seems to show that it was non James extravagant giving that caused his financial problems.In source decade, Matthew Hutton states that, His loftinesss subjects reveal and fear that King James heroical and excellent nature is as well inclined to giving and that this will soon exhaust the treasury of his solid ground, thusly implying that Jamess extravagant nature was and will be the cause of his financial problems. This is yet backed up by source cardinal as it states that James is very generous with his gifts and that gifts to the scots atomic number 18 causing an incur open leak from the cistern, this is demonstrating how James extravagance is caus ing him financial trouble.Whereas on the face of it source eleven seems to disagree with the other both sources as it demonstrates how it was not James extravagance that was causing him financial trouble. In this source it states that payments to the king, for example taxes argon not paid or self-possessed and overly The Earl of Dorset goes on to say that the fact James I has a family is another reason for his financial trouble.Furthermore as this this is a letter from the manufacturing business Treasurer to The Chancellor of the Exchequer this is the close trustworthy source approximately whether it was James extravagance that was causing him financial problems as between them they are the people who look after and maintain the treasury. However it can be argued that all three sources agree to a large extent that it was not James extravagant soulality that caused his financial problems.Firstly in source twelve it does not specifically say that he is extravagant also at the time it was written, 1604, James the I was not actually in debt and so this is not a very reliable source to find erupt whether James extravagance caused him financial problems. Source twelve can also back up the point that it was not James extravagant giving that caused him financial difficulty as it states that, Parliament could replenish the treasury of his Majesty Treasury.This implies that it was parliament who caused James financial troubles as they did not give him the silver needed to suffice all of his needs, and so in order to conduct with others he had to resort to giving as he was not presumptuousness the money needed to create an army. Also, in source twelve the person who wrote the letter was not a part of the government and so this actor that he would not have been that close to James to be able to judge whether he was an extravagant giver or not.This is backed up further by his statement, I understand from common talk thus implying that these are just rumours an d so they are not a reliable source of cultivation for the listener, in this case John More, and as the information was not reliable that makes the source not reliable. Furthermore, as source ten was written a few years earlier the rest it was not that reliable and this was further proved by the fact that it is written before the time that James ends up in debt.Therefore the sources, when taken together, show that it was not James Is extravagant giving that caused his financial difficulties, provided that there were a lot of contributing factors stated in source eleven which is the most reliable source and should therefore have the most weight put onto it. This is because the source is between the two leading members who are looking after James Is money.And sources ten and twelve are not that reliable so they do have so much weight put onto them thus backing up further that it was not James extravagant personality as on the face of it that was they suggest but. But when the sourc es are looked at collectively they show that it was not James extravagant giving that caused him financial trouble. Brendon Head Word amount (686 words)